Older shotguns, cherished heirlooms or trusty hunting companions, often present a unique challenge for modern shooters: the use of non-toxic shot. While lead shot remains highly effective, environmental concerns and evolving regulations have driven the adoption of steel, bismuth, and other non-toxic alternatives. However, using these in older firearms requires careful consideration. This guide explores the compatibility of non-toxic shotgun shells with older guns, highlighting potential issues and offering solutions for safe and effective shooting.
Understanding the Challenges of Non-Toxic Shot in Older Guns
The primary concern when using non-toxic shot in older shotguns lies in the hardness of these alternatives compared to lead. Steel, for example, is significantly harder than lead. This increased hardness can lead to:
- Increased Barrel Wear: The harder shot can abrade the softer steel of older barrels more rapidly, potentially leading to premature wear and even damage.
- Increased Recoil: Non-toxic shot, particularly steel, often weighs less than lead shot of the same size. This can result in higher felt recoil, especially uncomfortable for older shooters or those less accustomed to heavier recoil.
- Pattern Degradation: The harder shot can deform more easily upon impact, potentially leading to a less consistent and tighter shot pattern. This is particularly relevant at longer ranges.
Case Study: The 1950s Ithaca 37
A classic example highlights these challenges. An Ithaca Model 37, a sturdy shotgun produced from the 1930s onwards, might exhibit increased barrel wear when consistently firing steel shot. The softer steel used in some older Ithaca barrels isn't as resistant to the abrasive nature of steel shot as modern barrels designed for it. While the gun itself might withstand the shot, its lifespan might be reduced compared to using lead shot.
Types of Non-Toxic Shot and Their Compatibility
Several non-toxic shot alternatives exist, each with varying degrees of compatibility with older shotguns:
1. Steel Shot:
- Pros: Widely available, relatively inexpensive.
- Cons: Hardest of the common alternatives, leading to significant barrel wear in older guns. May also cause higher recoil and less consistent patterns. Not recommended for older shotguns without prior testing or modifications.
2. Bismuth Shot:
- Pros: Denser than steel, leading to better patterns and reduced recoil compared to steel. Softer than steel, minimizing barrel wear.
- Cons: More expensive than steel.
3. Tungsten-Iron Shot:
- Pros: Extremely dense, leading to excellent patterns and minimal recoil. Relatively soft, reducing barrel wear.
- Cons: Most expensive option.
4. Other Alternatives:
- Hevi-Shot: A blend of tungsten and other metals, offering a balance between density, cost, and recoil.
- Tungsten-Polymer: A newer option combining tungsten with a polymer coating to reduce wear and increase penetration.
Table 1: Comparison of Non-Toxic Shot Types
| Shot Type | Hardness | Density | Cost | Recoil | Barrel Wear | Pattern |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steel | High | Low | Low | High | High | Fair |
| Bismuth | Medium | Medium | Medium | Medium | Low | Good |
| Tungsten-Iron | Low | High | High | Low | Low | Excellent |
| Hevi-Shot | Medium | High | High | Medium | Low | Good |
| Tungsten-Polymer | Low | High | High | Low | Very Low | Excellent |
Determining Compatibility: A Cautious Approach
Before using non-toxic shot in an older shotgun, proceed with extreme caution. Several steps can help determine compatibility:
-
Consult the Manufacturer: Check the manufacturer's specifications and any available literature for recommendations on shot type. This information, while sometimes limited for older guns, remains your most reliable starting point.
-
Inspect the Barrel: Examine the barrel for any signs of erosion or excessive wear. Older guns may already have imperfections that will accelerate with harder shot.
-
Start with Low-Velocity Loads: Begin with low-velocity ammunition to minimize stress on the barrel. Gradually increase velocity only after confirming safe operation at lower velocities.
-
Regular Inspection: Inspect the barrel after every shooting session for any signs of damage or excessive wear. The appearance of fine scratches or unusual wear patterns should be a warning sign to cease using non-toxic shot.
-
Professional Evaluation: Consider a professional gunsmith evaluation for a definitive assessment of compatibility with specific non-toxic shot types. This is advisable for older or particularly valuable firearms.
Conclusion: Balancing Tradition and Modernity
Shooting older shotguns with non-toxic shot requires a balanced approach. While the environmental benefits are clear, potential damage to the firearm must be carefully considered. Following these guidelines and prioritizing careful inspection will help ensure both the safe operation of your older shotgun and the responsible use of non-toxic ammunition. Choosing the right shot type, based on your gun's condition and your budget, is crucial for maintaining its longevity and enjoying ethical and responsible shooting.