Are Glock 17 and 19 magazines interchangeable? This is a common question among Glock owners and enthusiasts. The short answer is: mostly yes, but with some important caveats. While they share significant similarities, there are subtle differences that can affect functionality and reliability. This article will delve into the specifics, exploring the compatibility issues and offering practical advice.
Understanding Glock 17 and 19 Magazine Design
Both the Glock 17 and Glock 19 are incredibly popular handguns known for their reliability and ease of use. They share a common lineage and many design elements, including the use of polymer frames and striker-fired mechanisms. This shared DNA extends to their magazines, leading to their near-interchangeability.
Key Similarities in Magazine Design
- Basic Dimensions: Glock 17 and 19 magazines are very similar in width and overall profile. This similarity is the foundation of their compatibility.
- Feed Lip Design: The feed lips, responsible for guiding the cartridges into the chamber, are essentially identical. This ensures reliable feeding in most cases.
- Follower Design: The magazine followers, which push the cartridges up towards the feed lips, are also very similar.
Subtle Differences Affecting Interchangeability
Despite their similarities, crucial differences exist.
-
Magazine Length: The most obvious difference is length. The Glock 17 magazine is longer, holding 17 rounds in its standard configuration (compared to the Glock 19's 15 rounds). This extra length is the primary factor influencing compatibility issues.
-
Baseplate Design: Although often visually similar, there might be minor variations in the baseplate design between Glock 17 and 19 magazines. These variations aren't always noticeable but can impact how securely the magazine sits in the grip.
-
Manufacturing Tolerances: Even within the same model (Glock 17 or 19), minor manufacturing tolerances exist. This means that a magazine from one production run might fit slightly differently in a pistol from another run, regardless of whether it's a G17 or G19.
Practical Implications of Interchangeability
So, what does this mean for the Glock owner?
-
Glock 19 Magazines in a Glock 17: Generally, Glock 19 magazines will fit and function reliably in a Glock 17. The shorter length simply leaves some extra space in the magazine well. This isn't a problem for function.
-
Glock 17 Magazines in a Glock 19: This is where problems might arise. The longer Glock 17 magazine might be difficult to insert completely into the Glock 19's magazine well. You might experience resistance or even be unable to seat the magazine fully. If forcefully inserted, you risk damaging the magazine or the firearm.
-
Reliability Concerns: Even if a Glock 17 magazine does fit into a Glock 19, reliable function is not guaranteed. The extra length could interfere with the feeding mechanism, causing malfunctions like failure to feed or stovepipes.
Case Study: User Experiences
Online forums and gun communities are filled with user experiences regarding Glock 17 and 19 magazine interchangeability. The consensus largely supports the above points: G19 mags in a G17 are usually problem-free. Conversely, using G17 mags in a G19 is often reported as unreliable, leading to malfunctions.
Recommendations and Best Practices
To avoid issues and ensure reliable operation, here's the advice:
-
Stick to the recommended magazines: Use Glock 17 magazines in your Glock 17, and use Glock 19 magazines in your Glock 19. This is the safest and most reliable approach.
-
Test thoroughly: If you do decide to try using different magazines, do so cautiously and thoroughly test the functionality. Fire several magazines through the gun to confirm reliable operation under various conditions.
-
Avoid force: Never force a magazine into the firearm. If you encounter resistance, stop immediately to avoid damaging the weapon.
Conclusion: Near, But Not Perfect Interchangeability
Glock 17 and 19 magazines are largely compatible, with Glock 19 magazines functioning well in a Glock 17. However, using a Glock 17 magazine in a Glock 19 should be approached cautiously due to potential reliability issues. Always prioritize the use of the magazine designed for your specific firearm to maintain reliability and safety.