The AR-15 platform's versatility is legendary, and a key part of that versatility lies in its customizable nature. One area of customization that sparks considerable debate among AR-15 enthusiasts is the carry handle upper receiver. This guide will delve into the details of carry handle AR-15s, exploring their history, advantages, disadvantages, and ultimately helping you decide if this classic design is right for you.
The History and Nostalgia of the Carry Handle AR-15
The carry handle upper receiver was the original design for the M16 rifle, and it remains a potent symbol of military history and classic firearm aesthetics. Its integrated carrying handle housed the rear sight, providing a robust and reliable aiming system. This design was functional, simplifying the manufacturing process and providing a built-in way to transport the rifle. The evolution of the AR-15 platform, however, has largely moved away from this design, opting for detachable carry handles and even picatinny rails for greater customization.
The Rise of Picatinny Rails and Detachable Carry Handles
The advent of the Picatinny rail system revolutionized the AR-15's adaptability. This standardized rail system allowed for the mounting of virtually any optic, sight, or accessory imaginable, leading to a decline in the popularity of the integrated carry handle. While still appreciated by many for its vintage appeal and inherent strength, the flattop upper receiver, with its Picatinny rail, offered unparalleled flexibility. Detachable carry handles emerged as a compromise, offering the nostalgic look with modern adaptability, often featuring a Picatinny rail on top for added versatility.
Advantages of a Carry Handle AR-15
Despite the shift towards flattop uppers, the carry handle design maintains some distinct advantages:
-
Enhanced Durability: The carry handle upper receiver is often considered more robust than its flattop counterpart. The integrated design adds rigidity to the upper receiver, potentially reducing the risk of damage under harsh conditions.
-
Built-in Rear Sight: The integrated rear sight eliminates the need for a separate rear sight, simplifying setup and reducing cost. This is particularly appealing for those on a budget or who prioritize simplicity.
-
Classic Aesthetics: Many shooters appreciate the classic military look and feel of the carry handle design. It represents a connection to the rifle's history and a more traditional aesthetic.
-
Potential Weight Savings (in some cases): While not always true, some carry handle uppers can be lighter than equivalent flattop models. This is dependent on the specific manufacturer and materials.
Disadvantages of a Carry Handle AR-15
The carry handle design, however, also presents several drawbacks:
-
Limited Optic Options: The most significant disadvantage is the restricted optic mounting options. While some carry handle uppers incorporate Picatinny rails, the limited space significantly restricts the types and sizes of optics that can be used. Red dot sights are often the only viable option without significant modifications.
-
Eye Relief Considerations: The fixed position of the carry handle's rear sight can affect eye relief, making it less comfortable for shooters who prefer a different cheek weld or eye position.
-
Weight Distribution: The weight of the carry handle can alter the balance of the rifle compared to a flattop. Some shooters find this less desirable for certain shooting styles.
-
Less Versatility: The inability to easily mount accessories other than optics directly to the carry handle limits its overall customization potential.
Carry Handle vs. Flattop: A Direct Comparison
| Feature | Carry Handle | Flattop |
|---|---|---|
| Optic Mounting | Limited to built-in or limited rail space | Extensive Picatinny rail space |
| Durability | Generally considered more robust | Can be equally robust with quality materials |
| Weight | Can be lighter or heavier (manufacturer dependent) | Generally comparable weight |
| Cost | Often less expensive initially | Can be more or less expensive (depending on upgrades) |
| Customization | Limited | Highly customizable |
| Aesthetics | Classic military look | Modern, clean look |
Choosing the Right Upper Receiver for Your Needs
The decision between a carry handle and a flattop upper receiver ultimately depends on individual preferences and intended use. If you prioritize simplicity, durability, and the classic look, a carry handle might be suitable. However, if you need maximum versatility, optic flexibility, and extensive customization options, a flattop upper receiver is almost certainly the better choice. Consider your budget, shooting style, and preferred optics before making your decision.
Conclusion: Carry Handle AR-15 - A Piece of History
The carry handle AR-15 is more than just a firearm; it's a piece of history. While it may not be the most versatile or modern option, its unique characteristics and nostalgic appeal continue to attract a dedicated following. Understanding its advantages and disadvantages allows you to make an informed decision based on your individual needs and preferences. Whether you choose a traditional carry handle or the modern flattop, the AR-15 platform offers unmatched adaptability.