Choosing between the Remington 870 Wingmaster and the Remington 870 Fieldmaster can be tough. Both are legendary pump-action shotguns, renowned for reliability and performance. However, subtle differences cater to distinct shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will highlight the key distinctions to help you make an informed decision. Understanding the nuances of each model will ensure you select the perfect shotgun for your needs, whether it's hunting, sport shooting, or home defense.
Key Differences: Wingmaster vs. Fieldmaster
The core differences between the Wingmaster and the Fieldmaster lie in their features and intended use. While both share the same robust 870 action, variations in stock, barrel, and receiver finish impact their overall feel and purpose.
Stock and Forend
-
Wingmaster: Features a classic, high-gloss walnut stock and forend. This provides a more traditional, elegant look and feel, often preferred by collectors and those seeking a more refined aesthetic. The wood is usually higher grade than the Fieldmaster’s, contributing to a more polished feel.
-
Fieldmaster: Typically sports a matte-finished synthetic stock and forend. This is more durable and resistant to the elements, making it ideal for harsh conditions and frequent use in the field. Synthetic stocks are also generally lighter than wood, reducing overall weight.
Barrel and Receiver
-
Wingmaster: Often comes with a blued steel receiver and barrel, lending a classic, somewhat more formal appearance. Bluing provides corrosion resistance, but can be more susceptible to wear and tear compared to newer finishes.
-
Fieldmaster: May offer a blued steel finish, but also frequently features a more durable, modern coating like a hard-anodized finish on the receiver. This is more resistant to scratches and corrosion, making it better suited for rugged use. The barrel is often designed for a specific purpose, like hunting or sporting clays, and might have different chokes.
Receiver Finish
-
Wingmaster: The high-gloss blued steel receiver offers a visually appealing finish but requires more care to maintain its appearance.
-
Fieldmaster: Its receiver finish may be matte blued steel or a more resilient hard-anodized finish. The latter is more resistant to scratches and wear and tear which is beneficial in hunting or fieldwork.
Choosing the Right Shotgun: Wingmaster or Fieldmaster?
The best choice depends heavily on your intended use and personal preferences. Consider the following factors:
Hunting
-
Fieldmaster: Its synthetic stock and more durable finishes make it a superior choice for hunting in various terrains and weather conditions. The lighter weight is also advantageous when carrying the gun for extended periods.
-
Wingmaster: While usable for hunting, its wood stock is less durable and may not withstand the rigors of harsh environments as effectively.
Target Shooting/Sporting Clays
- Either model can work well: Both offer the reliability needed for competitive shooting. Your choice might come down to personal preference for stock type and aesthetics.
Home Defense
- Either model is suitable: Both provide the stopping power needed for home defense. The lighter Fieldmaster may be easier to maneuver in close quarters, but the Wingmaster's solid feel might be preferred by some users.
Collecting
- Wingmaster: Due to its classic design and high-quality walnut stock, the Wingmaster is a highly sought-after collector's item.
Table Summarizing Key Differences
| Feature | Wingmaster | Fieldmaster |
|---|---|---|
| Stock Material | High-gloss Walnut | Matte Synthetic |
| Stock Finish | High-gloss | Matte |
| Receiver Finish | Blued Steel | Blued Steel or Hard-Anodized |
| Durability | Moderate | High |
| Weight | Slightly Heavier | Slightly Lighter |
| Price | Generally Higher | Generally Lower |
| Ideal Use | Hunting, Collecting, Target | Hunting, Field Use, Home Defense |
Conclusion: Make the Right Choice
Both the Remington 870 Wingmaster and Fieldmaster are excellent shotguns. The ultimate decision depends on your individual needs and priorities. Carefully consider your shooting style, the environments in which you'll use the shotgun, and your budget. If you prioritize durability and weather resistance, the Fieldmaster is the logical choice. If you prefer classic aesthetics and a more refined feel, the Wingmaster is a compelling option. Investing in either will give you a dependable and versatile firearm for years to come.