Choosing the right over-and-under shotgun can be a daunting task, especially when comparing two highly regarded models like the Beretta 686 and the Beretta 687. Both are renowned for their quality, reliability, and performance, but key differences exist that cater to different shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which Beretta over-and-under is the perfect fit for you.
Understanding the Core Differences: Beretta 686 vs. 687
The Beretta 686 and 687 are both popular over-and-under shotguns, but the 687 represents a significant evolution in design and features. Here's a breakdown of their key distinctions:
Action Type:
-
Beretta 686: Features a monobloc action, meaning the entire action is a single piece of steel. This design is known for its robust construction and simplicity. It's highly durable and generally requires less maintenance.
-
Beretta 687: Employs a Steelium Plus barrel system, which is comprised of a reinforced steel monoblock action. While maintaining the strength of the 686's monobloc, it introduces a refined, more streamlined design. This leads to slightly reduced weight and improved balance for some shooters.
Ejectors vs. Extractors:
-
Beretta 686: Typically available with extractors, meaning spent cartridges are simply pulled out of the chambers. This is a simpler, more cost-effective system.
-
Beretta 687: Usually features ejectors, which actively throw spent shells clear of the gun. This is generally preferred by many shooters for faster follow-up shots, particularly in fast-paced situations like sporting clays. Note that some 686 models are available with ejectors as well, blurring the lines somewhat.
Receiver Design and Aesthetics:
-
Beretta 686: Presents a more classic and traditional receiver design. It's often seen as a more understated, workmanlike approach.
-
Beretta 687: Often boasts a sleeker, more modern receiver design, with finer engravings and more polished aesthetics. This translates to a more refined and sophisticated look.
Pricing:
Generally speaking, the Beretta 686 is slightly less expensive than the Beretta 687. This price difference reflects the more advanced features and manufacturing processes employed in the 687.
Key Features and Specifications: A Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Beretta 686 | Beretta 687 |
|---|---|---|
| Action Type | Monobloc | Steelium Plus |
| Ejectors/Extractors | Usually Extractors, some ejector models | Usually Ejectors |
| Receiver | Classic, functional design | Sleeker, modern design |
| Weight | Slightly heavier | Slightly lighter |
| Price | Generally less expensive | Generally more expensive |
| Barrel Options | Wide variety available | Wide variety available |
| Choke System | Typically Optima HP or Mobilchoke | Typically Optima HP or Mobilchoke |
Choosing the Right Gun: Beretta 686 or 687?
The "best" gun depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences.
-
Choose the Beretta 686 if:
- You prioritize a rugged, reliable shotgun with a simple design.
- You are on a tighter budget.
- You prefer a more traditional aesthetic.
- You don't need the speed advantage of ejectors.
-
Choose the Beretta 687 if:
- You want a more refined, modern-looking shotgun.
- You value faster follow-up shots provided by ejectors.
- You appreciate the slightly lighter weight and improved balance (although this is subjective).
- You're willing to pay a premium for enhanced features.
Case Study: Comparing Performance in Sporting Clays
While both shotguns excel in various disciplines, let's consider their performance in sporting clays. A shooter accustomed to the faster action of ejectors might find the 687's quicker target acquisition beneficial. However, a seasoned shooter proficient with extractors may not notice a significant difference in performance between the two models. The actual performance difference largely hinges on the shooter's skill and experience, rather than the inherent capabilities of the shotguns themselves.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice
Both the Beretta 686 and 687 are exceptional over-and-under shotguns. The ultimate choice comes down to your individual needs, shooting style, budget, and aesthetic preferences. Careful consideration of the features outlined above will guide you toward the perfect Beretta for your shooting journey. Remember to handle both models if possible before making a final decision. This hands-on experience will provide invaluable insight into which shotgun feels best in your hands.