Choosing the right high-speed steel (HST) for a particular application is crucial for optimal performance and tool life. Two popular grades, 124 and 147 HST, often come up in discussions. While both are high-performance tool steels, they possess distinct characteristics that make them suitable for different machining operations. This article delves into the specifics of 124 vs. 147 HST, helping you understand their differences and choose the best option for your needs.
Understanding High-Speed Steel (HST)
Before comparing 124 and 147 HST, it's beneficial to understand the fundamental properties of high-speed steel. HST is a type of tool steel known for its high hardness at elevated temperatures, enabling it to withstand the heat generated during high-speed machining operations. This characteristic distinguishes it from carbon steels and allows for significantly faster cutting speeds and improved productivity. The high hardness is achieved through alloying elements such as tungsten, molybdenum, vanadium, and chromium. These elements contribute to the steel's red hardness, which is the ability to retain its hardness at high temperatures.
Comparing 124 and 147 HST: Key Differences
Both 124 and 147 HST are widely used in various applications, but their compositions and resulting properties differ, leading to distinct performance characteristics.
Compositional Differences:
| Element | 124 HST (Approximate Percentage) | 147 HST (Approximate Percentage) |
|---|---|---|
| Tungsten (W) | 18-20 | 6-8 |
| Molybdenum (Mo) | 1-1.5 | 5-6 |
| Vanadium (V) | 1-1.5 | 1-2 |
| Chromium (Cr) | 4-5 | 4-5 |
| Carbon (C) | 0.7-0.9 | 0.7-0.9 |
Note: These are approximate values, and the exact composition can vary slightly depending on the manufacturer.
Performance Characteristics:
-
124 HST: This grade is characterized by its high toughness and wear resistance. It is often preferred for applications requiring high impact resistance and where there is a risk of tool breakage. It offers excellent performance in roughing and semi-finishing operations on various materials.
-
147 HST: This grade exhibits superior red hardness and hot hardness compared to 124 HST. This makes it ideal for high-speed cutting applications where heat generation is significant. It excels in finishing operations and applications requiring a fine surface finish.
Applications:
-
124 HST: Suitable for roughing cuts, semi-finishing cuts, and applications involving interrupted cuts or high impact loads. Common uses include milling, drilling, and turning of tough materials like stainless steel and cast iron.
-
147 HST: Ideal for high-speed finishing operations, producing accurate and smooth surfaces. Frequently used in applications such as precision grinding, honing, and fine turning of high-strength alloys and steels.
Tool Life Comparison:
While direct comparison of tool life depends heavily on the specific application (cutting speed, feed rate, depth of cut, material being machined), generally, 147 HST tends to show longer tool life in high-speed finishing operations due to its superior red hardness. However, 124 HST might offer better tool life in roughing operations where toughness is crucial and the risk of breakage is high.
Case Study: Milling Stainless Steel
Let's consider a case study involving milling stainless steel. For roughing operations, the high toughness of 124 HST would be advantageous, minimizing the risk of chip breakage and tool failure. However, for finishing the surface, 147 HST's superior red hardness and ability to maintain a sharp edge at high temperatures would result in a smoother, more precise finish with potentially longer tool life.
Choosing the Right Grade:
The selection between 124 and 147 HST ultimately depends on the specific machining operation, the material being machined, and the desired surface finish. Consider these factors:
- Material: For tough materials prone to causing high impact loads, 124 HST may be preferred. For high-strength alloys requiring fine finishes, 147 HST is generally a better choice.
- Machining Operation: Roughing operations often benefit from the toughness of 124 HST, while finishing operations benefit from the red hardness of 147 HST.
- Cutting Speed: High-speed machining operations are better suited to 147 HST due to its superior hot hardness.
By carefully considering these factors, you can select the appropriate HST grade to optimize your machining processes and achieve desired results. Remember to consult with your tool supplier for recommendations based on your specific application.